No doubt you’ve already heard the news. This week, the New Jersey Supreme Court unanimously ruled that more than 20,000 DWI charges are invalid due to errors in calibrating Alcotest breath test devices. A whole lot of defendants are likely sighing in relief. After all, the Supreme Court’s ruling may make all the difference in setting up legal defenses for charges in violation of N.J.S.A. 39:4-50. (This is commonly referred to as the drunk driving statute.)
First, what is an Alcotest? Many think of the term breathalyzer as the device used by police to estimate a suspect’s blood alcohol count (BAC). However, Alcotest devices are a particular brand name manufactured by Draeger Safety Diagnostics. Among other things, the machine must be calibrated in order to produce accurate results.
In State v. Cassidy, New Jersey Supreme Court Justice Walter Timpone agreed with a special master that a state police technician failed to properly calibrate Alcotest 7110 breath test machines used on suspected drunk drivers. What happened? It appears that the police sergeant didn’t use the proper thermometer specified by the New Jersey Supreme Court in an earlier case, State v. Chun.
Alcotest Results Found Invalid
First, some quick facts about the Supreme Court’s decision. Unfortunately, the defendant Eileen Cassidy is now deceased. She originally pled guilty to charges that she was driving while intoxicated based solely on what she believed were the Alcotest results. Notably, it was Cassidy’s third conviction, and the associated penalties were high.
Subsequent to her day in court, the news came out with some big headlines. It seems there was evidence that a police sergeant failed to properly handle the calibration of the devices. Therefore, the scientific reliability of the results made them questionable. Cassidy decided to withdraw her guilty plea.
Last May, retired Appellate Division Judge Joseph Lisa acting as special master held that failure to use a NIST (National Institute of Science and Technology) traceable thermometer specified in Chun “raises substantial doubts about the scientific reliability of breath test results produced by Alcotest devices…”
The New Jersey Supreme Court concurred. Its ruling concluded that the police technician failed to calibrate breath tests used in more than 20,600 cases over seven years in Middlesex, Monmouth, Ocean, Somerset and Union counties. Although the majority of the flawed test results occurred in those counties, the problem actually extends to twelve counties.
What does this mean? DWI convictions will need to be retried, while those still pending might have to be abandoned. In fact, you could be impacted if you were accused of DWI between 2008 and 2016.
This case is a win for defense counsels across New Jersey because it may provide grounds to appeal a DWI conviction because of the Alcotest test results being inadmissible. Ultimately, the prosecution has the burden of proof in field sobriety cases.
If you have been charged with DWI, you should seek legal counsel, especially if this new Supreme Court case may impact you. The Law Offices of Beninato & Matrafaljo has extensive experience representing those charged with DWI. Contact us now to schedule a consultation.
Dan is hands down the best lawyer out there. He will work diligently to achieve the best possible outcome for you and your family.
19:20 27 Feb 20
I can say without a doubt .. Dan Matrafajlo is an outstanding attorney. 5+ stars . He & his firm represented me on my worker’s compensation case . Years ago. Did right not only by me but my wife & friends as well. Danny & his firm continues to represent me . Will always represent me .. and our most recent my son who got ticketed for allegedly speeding and illegal lane change on the parkway which I know many many drivers have been ticketed for the same violations when you know You haven’t committed it. But!!!.. Dan Matrafajlo got my sons tickets dismissed. This attorney & his firm know what there doing . And are the the best . Talk about hitting the trifecta. Beniato & Matrafajlo firm and all his staff and attorneys . Get the job done. The best ..super lawyer. Google him you’ll see I’m not B.Sn you .
16:52 07 Feb 20
Thank you ....and your associate best lawyer in town GOD bless ...
00:16 30 Jan 20
I had a work related incident on 11/2017. I immediately google reviewed a workers comp attorney. Beninato & Matrafajlo Law firm revealed extremely positive reviews. Without a hesitation I drove to their Elizabeth location seeking help. Attorney Andrew was very polite, courteous and resourceful with aiding my problems. Andrew assistant was just as helpful. They kept me updated throughout the entire process via phone or email. The doctors they administered to me were pleasant as well. Even though the process took nearly 2yrs - Andrew was alongside for entire journey. On May 29, 2019 I finally went to court for work incident. Andrew prompt me on entire court process making me feel comfy and confident before speaking in front of judge. After the ordeal Beninato & Matrafajlo Law firm followed up making sure I was completely satisfied with everything. I wouldn’t of chosen anyone else! Thank You Andrew, his assistant & entire Law firm for the marvelous experience.
18:56 28 Jan 20
15:02 03 Dec 19
15:21 28 Oct 19
DAN is a great lawyer!!!Far exceeded my expectations.. answered all my questions personally and walked me through the whole process... THANKS
Dan is a lawyer you want on your side, he was on point , always working on strategies on my case. btw we won our case!!! When it matters to you call him. Thanks Again Beninato & Matrafajlo
22:11 16 Jul 19
Best Lawyer ever very professional flights to the very end To make sure his client is happy with the decision of a case
01:44 28 Jun 19
Dan is the best lawyer I have ever met he did not give up he said he was going to help me and that's definitely what he did I am grateful to have him as my attorney and I will highly recommend him to anyone looking for help p.s and everyone that works at the office is extremely professional polites and very nice and I thank you as well keep up the great work
10:54 20 May 19
Mr. Matrafajlo and his staff are both professional and kind. He went to court 5 times over 6+months fighting a traffic ticket that would of suspended my license and caused me thousands in fine and surcharges. It was dismissed with zero owed to the courts after proving DMV administrative discrepancies. Thank you so much for all your helpRenee
14:07 11 May 19
Mr. Matrafajlo and his staff are both professional and kind. He went to court 5 times over 6+months fighting a traffic ticket that would of suspended my...
First of all, I admired Dan for his understanding by putting himself on his clients shoes and fight for their best interest (outcome). For me, the definition of a great lawyer are those who "deliver" and he does.
16:22 03 Apr 19
I am writing this review almost a decade after the fact......Mr. Matrafajlo is an excellent attorney. He did everything in his power to help me out. I would recommend him to anyone that was in need of an attorney.
23:24 01 Mar 19
The best of the best! I would definitely recommend Dan to my family and friends. Very professional and goes above and beyond to answer questions and to get the best results!
20:43 18 Jan 19
I got a 3 point ticket for doing an unsafe turn. I ended up hiring Matrafajlo. He seemed pretty confident he can get the ticket reduced to obstruction of...
I would definitely recommend Dan and his team to friends and family. The staff was very knowledgeable and helpful every time I reached out with questions. Dan and Teresa aka the Dream Team!! Everyone went above and beyond for little ‘ol me! Job well done!!
18:29 07 Nov 18
Dan really went above and beyond for my case . I was wrongfully accused of reckless driving . He could of just told me to take first plea deal and been done with it . Instead he suggested I refuse . The prosecutor in turn ran us around for months refusing to budge. Dan was sted fast in his support for me and never wavered. What started as a reckless driving which is a criminal offense ended as an unsafe driving ( 0 point offense). All thanks to Dan's hard work and perseverance
23:13 16 Sep 18
The best of the best, there's no other choice if you're looking for legal representation. Simply an incredible attorney. Helped me get out of a serious jam.
22:51 08 May 18
Dan Matrafajlo was fantastic. From the moment I hired him he handled everything from scheduling my court date to representing me with my traffic ticket. Literally, all I had to do was show up to court. He put me at ease throughout the whole process and had my fine reduced dramatically!! I highly recommend him.
A J Sports
02:40 26 Apr 18
Dan Matrafajlo one the best attorneys ever I was completely satisfied and he has one of the best teams working for him .. I would and have recommended him .
Represented my mother when she had an accident, highly recommend him as an attorney
20:57 25 Mar 18
I don't know much about Beninato but I know a lot about Matrafajlo Danny Matrafajlo is very ambitious, smart, knowlegable, helpful lawyer I have ever know.Keep that way DannyHappy Thanksgiving to you and your family
Few months back, my husband had injured in a car accident. It seemed to be a small injury, but in fact it was brain injury and the truck who hit our car, ran away. We were so confused that how to survive and get compensation for brain injury. At that time, from my friend's reference, I got to know about Beninato & Matrafajlo Law, The firm handled our case very carefully and passionately, took the right steps for us and helped us in getting compensation. Thanks to Beninato & Matrafajlo Law!
05:42 26 Jul 17
Dan is an outstanding lawyer he has handled personal injury cases for me for a couple of my friends he has handled matrimonial and Municipal Court tickets and everyone is happy with his services
20:05 23 Jul 17
I was referred to Dan Mantrafajlo by a dear friend of my that I respect greatly. This friend said that Dan was the type of lawyer that made the hard work she was putting into law school worth it...I found this to be very true. Professional, hard working, informed and willing to go above and beyond. This is a real review from a real client.
08:12 20 Jul 17
Very professional. I highly recommend it to anybody.
01:46 12 Jul 17
Simply put he is the best! He was professional, prompt and always acted in my best interest. Couldn't have expected a better outcome.
Mr. Matrafajlo has represented me in a civil case where I was struck and injured by another vehicle.His professionalism and hard work truly made my experience seamless. There will be unpredictable measures that life throws at you, it always helps to have someone you trust by your side.I highly recommend Mr. Matrafajlo or anyone in this law firm to represent them if need be.-Zack
Dan is an excellent attorney. Unlike most attorneys Dan actually cares about your case. He went the extra mile and did countless hours of research to help me win my case. I'd give him 10 stars if I was able to.
14:44 31 Mar 15
I starting using Dan after a VERY bad experience with a previous attorney who took advantage of our family. Dan is a great lawyer and very competent. While he specializes in personal injury, he and his office staff proved themselves on multiple occasions to be more then competent in other areas of the law. He's quick to respond and always makes us feel like our case is his top priority. I have since referred him to multiple people and their experience has been a positive one as well. His rates are reasonable and he has no desire to drag things out, file extension after extension etc. and rack up my bill as our previous attorney did. We highly recommend Dan Matrafajilo Esq., as does everyone I know who have used his services before.
"No aspect of this advertisement has been approved by the Supreme Court of New Jersey"
The information on this New Jersey Attorney / Law Firm website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this or associated pages, documents, comments, answers, emails, or other communications should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information on this website is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing of this information does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. ~ Dan Matrafajlo on Google+